Search

Review of American Tattoo Society

American Tattoo Society: If you're looking for a tattoo or piercing shop that offers a wide range of services, look no further than American Tattoo Society. This Fayetteville-based business offers everything from tattoos and body piercings to ear piercings and permanent makeup. With a primary category of tattoo shop, American Tattoo Society is known for its clean, modern, and professional atmosphere.

The staff at American Tattoo Society are friendly, helpful, and highly skilled. Customers rave about the quality of work done by the artists, particularly Vanessa, Cory, and Billy. Vanessa, in particular, is known for her incredible line work and attention to detail.

Customers also appreciate the professionalism and promptness of the service at American Tattoo Society. The shop is open seven days a week, with hours that extend into the evening. Walk-ins are welcome, and the staff are always happy to answer questions and help customers choose the right design or piercing.

While most customers have had positive experiences at American Tattoo Society, there have been a few negative reviews. Some customers have complained about the cost of touch-ups or the quality of work done by certain artists. However, these negative reviews are few and far between, and the overwhelming majority of customers have had great experiences at this shop.

If you're looking for a tattoo or piercing shop in Fayetteville, American Tattoo Society is definitely worth checking out. With a wide range of services, highly skilled artists, and a professional atmosphere, this shop is a great choice for anyone looking to get inked or pierced.

From the business

"Fayetteville and Fort Bragg's premiere tattoo shop."

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • In-store shopping
  • Same-day delivery

American Tattoo Society Reviews - 100

4.7
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Valerie Johnson

I have known Ryan and Nicole for a few years and you couldn’t find a more professional or hardworking couple. They have high expectations from their employees which results in very satisfied customers. In my opinion, what sets them apart from other tattoo shops is their incredible work ethic which is unprecedented. My daughter is set to have a second ear piercing and I couldn’t imagine having that done anywhere else.

Bre Mooney

I actually didn't intend to get a piercing the first time I walked into American Tattoo Society. I was there to support a friend getting her first one. But the more I talked to Lyn, the more I realized, "okay, this woman is amazing, and I want her to pierce me." The only problem was, I had no idea what piercing I wanted!
When she finished my friend's ear (which turned out perfectly), Lyn turned to me and just looked at my face for a moment, considering what I'd look best with. We decided on a vertical philtrum, something I'd never even thought of before. She meticulously marked my face and lip, and had me double and triple check that it was perfectly straight and I was happy with the placement. She was incredibly professional through the whole process, which was nearly painless, but still so sweet and friendly.
My piercing has healed up incredibly well, and I'm excited to have found "my" piercer. She's the only one who will be putting any metal in my face from now on!
I cannot recommend Lyn enough, and all of the staff I met were just as lovely. It's hard to find a shop where you really feel at home, but I've definitely found mine.

Nicole Rogers Grey

I got my very first tattoo here and at first I was a little intimidated cause I was only 18 and I only wanted a small flamingo. The staff made me feel very comfortable and told me everything I needed to know about the tattoo and care for it afterwards. Since that day I've gone back for an additional two tattoos and a piercing! The best work and best prices in town! I love this place!

Edit: Another tattoo, cosmetic tattoos and a piercing later. I still go back to this place time and time again. Megan is amazing at what she does! Can’t wait to see the final result of my eyebrows! 🤩

Nichelle West

My piercers name was BRI and she did a septum piercing for me and my daughter.She was so cool and talked with us the whole time .Super friendly and all the questions that we ask she was very informative and helpful.She made sure we were all right and asked us if we need to lay down or needed water or anything really nice! It went by really fast and I would go back to her for more piercings in the future.

Savanna Freeman

Awesome experience! My husband and son got their ears pierced. The piercer was very patient with our fearful son and calmed him down enough to get it done and fall in love with his new bling. We will be going back again.

Gina George

Every time I email them to make an appointment and/or get a price on a tattoo I want, I get a response extremely quick. The staff here are very friendly, talented and knowledgeable. The facility is very clean. I come here for all my tattoos!!!

Serenity briles

Bri was my piercer and she did an amazing job! I was in and out of the store in less than 10 minutes, she was friendly, quick and clean! I got my septum done here and it went great! I highly recommend the American Tattoo society for piercings!

Terri Graham

I absolutely love skin prick city and the artists there!!! My first time there they were kind enough to take my boyfriend in for a coverup. It was a walk in and took almost 7 hours (we didn't leave until 3 in the morning) but it was so worth it! It was done by Thesis and it looks great! I was so happy with the service and the people there that I decided to go back a few weeks later to get my first tattoo done! Sam did this one and he was awesome!! I plan to go back again to get my nipples pierced. The customer service is awesome as well. Every time I've been/go I always try and make sure Megan is there. She's my favorite! I love her so much! Can't wait to go back!

Ariel Breon

I originally came in with a nose ring to put in my nose and the piercer ended up snapping it before she could put it in. I was totally understanding because it was a cheaper find off of etsy, so I just went to the mall and bought another and came back. She said she wouldn't charge me for putting my septum piercing in because of the mistake. I came back and she put the new nose ring I had to go buy in for me. The guy at the front ended up charging me $10 for getting my nose ring put in. The last time I came, it only cost me $5 to put in jewelry I already had. Ended up getting charged for both piercing insertions even though I was told she wouldn't. I love the piercer there but not a big fan of the lack of communication between reception and the piercer. Very unhappy with this experience and likely won’t be back.

Cathy Fisher

Have been wanting to get my 2nd holes redone in my ears forever...got them done at Claire's when I was a kid & had some scar tissue. Lyn did an amazing job re-piercing my 2nd holes. Actually, she corrected them...they were uneven & 1 side was super low. It was quick & easy; she's friendly & down to earth, so if you're nervous about getting a piercing, I'd definitely recommend her!

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload

American Tattoo Society Hours

  • Monday 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Tuesday 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Wednesday 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Thursday 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Friday 11 AM to 11 PM
  • Saturday 11 AM to 11 PM
  • Sunday