Search

Review of American Tattoo Society

American Tattoo Society: If you're looking for a tattoo or piercing shop that offers a wide range of services, look no further than American Tattoo Society. This Fayetteville-based business offers everything from tattoos and body piercings to ear piercings and permanent makeup. With a primary category of tattoo shop, American Tattoo Society is known for its clean, modern, and professional atmosphere.

The staff at American Tattoo Society are friendly, helpful, and highly skilled. Customers rave about the quality of work done by the artists, particularly Vanessa, Cory, and Billy. Vanessa, in particular, is known for her incredible line work and attention to detail.

Customers also appreciate the professionalism and promptness of the service at American Tattoo Society. The shop is open seven days a week, with hours that extend into the evening. Walk-ins are welcome, and the staff are always happy to answer questions and help customers choose the right design or piercing.

While most customers have had positive experiences at American Tattoo Society, there have been a few negative reviews. Some customers have complained about the cost of touch-ups or the quality of work done by certain artists. However, these negative reviews are few and far between, and the overwhelming majority of customers have had great experiences at this shop.

If you're looking for a tattoo or piercing shop in Fayetteville, American Tattoo Society is definitely worth checking out. With a wide range of services, highly skilled artists, and a professional atmosphere, this shop is a great choice for anyone looking to get inked or pierced.

From the business

"Fayetteville and Fort Bragg's premiere tattoo shop."

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • In-store shopping
  • Same-day delivery

American Tattoo Society Reviews - 100

4.7
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Haleigh Hare

Haleigh Hare

πŸ‘ πŸ‘Ž 😐
Careless Outline Expensive

I went in and the staff were all very friendly and had availability for a walk in. I showed them my design and they got working almost immediately. They set me up with Kerry, who was very funny and very nice. He made sure to listen to my concerns since I’ve had some past issues with shading and whatnot. Overall the experience was good until I got home. When I got home and really looked at the tattoo, he was careless with the outline. He added an extra line that made the flower (the main piece) look weird. And the line was then curved around the other design in the tattoo because that line was not supposed to be there at all. It was also a little more expensive tattoo then I’ve paid at other places but I didn’t mind paying it at all since good tattoos aren’t cheap, the issue is this isn’t a great tattoo. I will give him credit for his shading though, the shading looks wonderful. Mistakes do happen but I wish there was more attention to detail when permanently tattooing something onto my body.

Ayana Ferguson

Ayana Ferguson

πŸ‘ πŸ‘Ž 😐
Fast Service Gentle Piercer No Pain

Went to their free piercing event, this past friday even though It was packed which was expected they were very fast, which was awesome. Got my nostril done piercer was very gentle and it didn't hurt at all. Will be going back soon.

Dena Rook

Dena Rook

πŸ‘ πŸ‘Ž 😐
Friendly Staff Highly Recommended

My daughter, our friend, and myself took advantage of the free piercings today. Amber and Megan were both great. Amber's mom was just as lovely. I highly recommend this place.

Haley Holland

Haley Holland

πŸ‘ πŸ‘Ž 😐
Friendly staff Clean shop Skilled artist Comfortable experience Good aftercare advice

i went here on a whim and im so glad i did. im visiting from Hawaii and just wanted to stop and see what was up. to start, everyone was extremely nice and quick at the front counter. no question was too dumb and they helped me get the design of what i wanted before i met my artist and then my artist made it perfect. the entire shop is so we’ll it and super clean, even the bathroom. i hate going to shops and it just looks like people live there. my artist was Billy and he was so patient and sweet. he made me feel very comfortable, got me some water, talked me through the process, and checked on me periodically to make sure i had everything i needed. when it came to the aftercare; this was only my second time having the full adhesive cover. i LOVE it. unlike my first time with it, when i removed it after a few days, my tattoo didn’t itch at all and barely scabbed. im so so happy i found then and Billy. couldn’t have asked for a better experience based on an impulsive decision lol. thanks again !

Serena Simpson

Serena Simpson

πŸ‘ πŸ‘Ž 😐
Friendly Staff Clean Environment Professional Service Fun Experience

Megan, the piercer, is AMAZING. Everyone else seemed friendly. I liked the vibes, it was clean. Megan was professionally, friendly, understanding, understanding, and just overall cool. She made it a fun experience rather than just getting a piercing.

Ronica McLeod

Ronica McLeod

πŸ‘ πŸ‘Ž 😐
Poor Quality Bad Customer Service Deceptive Practices

If I could give zero stars, I would I got a tattoo of my deceased dog's name on my finger on December 30th. I noticed the tattoo faded within 14 days. I went back to be told it was $100 to touch up my tattoo and that it’s their policy, and they brief everyone that finger tattoos fall off. I was not told this; I would’ve gotten the tattoo somewhere else. Below are pictures of the tattoo on Dec 30th and Jan. 13th.

Christopher

Christopher

πŸ‘ πŸ‘Ž 😐
Great Service Talented Artist Good Conversation

I walked in last night to get a tattoo done. I had a few I wanted done but it was super late so I settled for a simple one. My tattoo artist was David. Soft spoken polite gentleman that believes in treat others how you want to be treated. When I showed him the art I wanted on my leg, he was ecstatic especially when I asked him to throw his own design into it as well. Needless to say David did an amazing job, ten times better than what the picture looked like! And played great music and kept up good conversation. Also the other staff checked up on not only David but me as well to see if I needed a drink.

I'm coming back to get more ink done here. Definitely recommend.

Ed

Ed

πŸ‘ πŸ‘Ž 😐
Clean Shop Friendly Staff Talented Artist Great Personality Cover Up Tattoo Recommend George

This shop is clean and the staff is friendly but the star here is George Weibe, he is a very talented and versatile artist with an awesome personality. George worked with me to design a tattoo that would cover up a 37 year old tattoo. The black and grey design from my elbow down is the cover up. Then George re-colored another 37 year old traditional tattoo. I can't recommend George high enough. Read the many reviews on here and you will see his name mentioned over and over. If your considering a tattoo, call and make an appointment with George, you won't be disappointed.

Bonnie Lott

Thanks to Meagan and Nicole for a great piercing experience today!! You guys are awesome! Very friendly and gentle. Thanks so much!!

Anastasia Busbee

Had a wonderful time. Got a bit nervous but had support of several piercers who calmed me down. Thanks so much! Love my nose piercing.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload

American Tattoo Society Hours

  • Monday 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Tuesday 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Wednesday 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Thursday 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Friday 11 AM to 11 PM
  • Saturday 11 AM to 11 PM
  • Sunday