Search

Review of Colts Timeless Tattoos

Colts Timeless Tattoos: If you're looking for a tattoo or piercing shop in Neenah, Colts Timeless Tattoos is a great option. This shop offers both tattoo and piercing services, making it a one-stop-shop for all your body art needs.

The shop is open from 11:00 am to 7:00 pm Monday through Friday, making it convenient for those who work during the day. Unfortunately, the shop is closed on weekends, so you'll need to plan accordingly if you want to get a tattoo or piercing on a Saturday or Sunday.

Customers rave about the cleanliness of the shop, as well as the friendly and knowledgeable staff. Many customers specifically mention the excellent work done by Carli, Mandy, and Abby.

One customer describes the vibe of the shop as "super chill," with heavy metal music not being blasted at full volume. This customer also praises Carli's outstanding work and excellent communication during the tattoo process.

Another customer notes that Abby is the best piercer they've ever been to, while a third customer appreciates the shop's responsiveness and friendliness when they contacted them for more information.

While some customers have mentioned the shop's minimum charge, others have noted that the shop's work is worth the price. Overall, Colts Timeless Tattoos is a great option for those looking for a clean, friendly, and professional tattoo and piercing shop in Neenah.

From the business

"At Colt's Timeless Tattoos, we strive to build enduring customer relationships by providing a clean, safe, and friendly environment. We do our best to provide and deliver the best tattoo & body piercing experience to each and every one of our customers. We specialize in custom pieces unique to your needs and personality. Our artists specialize in various styles of tattooing, and we make every effort to find the absolute best artist for you and your project, so that you may proudly display this aesthetic extension of yourself. Please visit our website or send us a message/email if you are unsure of which artist might be best for you!"

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance

Colts Timeless Tattoos Reviews - 100

4.5
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Jules Brinkman

Got my first tattoo here during the summer it was perfect then and perfect now! Reasonal cost (especially for a broke college kid like me haha!) Colt's has very friendly service I felt very comfortable there! Im definetly going back for my next tattoo(s)!

Alex Lisowski

Ive had multiple piercings done here. One at the shop in the mall and one at the other location downtown. Both were great experiences. Quick healing and one didnt even swell or anything. Also got a tattoo done. Very large peice which was also a cover up and lots of color. Color turned out great. I didn't think i wanted color at first but when Matt was finished I loved it even more. Will Definately go back for any of my tattoo or piercing needs. Great shop. Great people.

Sydney Witt

Abby is the best piercer! She is funny and comforting. I got 5 piercings done at one time and she got them done fast. They aren't as even as I had hoped, but only I can tell! One of their old piercers came in while getting the 5 done and made me uncomfortable and very anxious- I would have preferred him not to come in the room and make silly jokes and stress me out more than I already was; but I know he was just goofing around. Months later, I had an AWFUL bump on my tragus from tearing it a little and walked in and asked for Abby, but instead the guy at the front counter insisted on helping me. Once he saw my tragus he did nothing to make me feel better or be comfortable. I felt judged and frustrated because I wanted to speak with Abby but he felt that he could step in to give his two cents. Finally she came out and gave me the help I wanted. All in all Abby is awesome and worth getting pierced from, the other guys need to work on their customer service skills and making sure their clients are comfortable when walking into an atmosphere they aren't that accustomed to. Thanks Abby!

Darin Kath

I am sending a huge shout out to Kelsey, and in turn the management.

There have been very few times in any state or country where I have felt more welcome on a phone call. it was actually fun learning about the many options and pros there.

Kelsey was so excited to teach me about the process, and she quelled my fears.

I will be referring my trusted friends, who like me, were skeptical.

Thank you.

The customer experience is what makes magic happen. Thank you Kelsey.

Brianna K

The guy that did my nose was really nice to both me and my mom. He was super friendly and I felt really comfortable getting my nose pierced! He explained everything I needed to know and it was overall a really great experience. Definitely would reccomend!

Sierra Dohm

If I could give no stars I would. They appear to have nice friendly service but are doing to get you're money. I paid $50 for a nose piercing and they didn't accommodate for swelling so it started to grow into my nose went to another piercer who fixed it at no charge ....most people know you have to account for swelling as common sense. Then I called it to get a copy of my receipt for biolife so I didn't get kicked out from donating plasma and the lady on the phone said she would send it out Monday and it's been over a month and I haven't seen anything so pretty fed up .....will never go back not professional at all.

Victoria Gau

The people were great, very nice and clean space. I absolutely love the work I got done too!

Always Abby

I didn’t actually get a tattoo from this place, but I did contact them for more information. They were super helpful and got back to me very quickly!!

Mike Pagel

2 consult appointments with Katrina, but she double booked herself and was not available with zero heads up. Now she is out and was told I would need to wait another 2 months to get in again.

Not professional, Katrina clearly doesn’t care about keeping appointments.

Brian Foley

Went here to get a simple tattoo. I have 15 tattoos and have never had any issues with any of them until I went here. The tattoo I received from Colts became infected immediately. I had to get it redone at another tattoo artist who said she can't believe it was done by a "professional". Won't go here anymore.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload

Colts Timeless Tattoos Hours

  • Monday 11 AM to 7 PM
  • Tuesday 11 AM to 7 PM
  • Wednesday 11 AM to 7 PM
  • Thursday 11 AM to 7 PM
  • Friday 11 AM to 7 PM
  • Saturday
  • Sunday